The Rum Bucket Bar & Grill.
Sunday: 11am-8pm
  • Sunday: 11am-8pm
  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: 11am-9pm
  • Wednesday: 11am-9pm
  • Thursday: 11am-9pm
  • Friday: 11am-10pm
  • Saturday: 11am-10pm
(239) 288-6975 Please Use Call Ahead Option
5150 Buckingham Rd
Fort Myers, FL 33905

Order Online

Navigation

  • Home
  • Menu
  • Bar
  • Music
  • Gift Cards
  • About
  • Contact
    • Group Events
    • Careers
    • Musician Booking
    • Rewards Program
    • Questions/Comments

The Menu

  • Appetizers
  • Salads
  • Handhelds
  • Fork & Knife
  • Fresh Catch
  • Signature Steaks
  • Sides
Now Offering Take-Out and
 Delivery with Online Orders!

APPETIZERS

  • GATOR BITES 16

    Gator tail breaded and fried and served with our house remoulade

  • BONELESS WINGS 13

    Tossed in your choice of: BBQ, teriyaki rum glaze, mango chili glaze, house buffalo, or dry

  • MAHI-MAHI SMOKED FISH DIP 15

    Smoked Mahi Mahi, served with a side of diced onions, jalapeños, and tortilla chips

  • ONION RING BASKET 11

    Jumbo breaded onions fried

  • FRIED MUSHROOMS 11

    Breaded fried whole mushrooms served with homemade buttermilk ranch

  • MAC & CHEESE BITES 10

    Mac & Cheese deep fried and served with homemade ranch

  • PEEL AND EAT SHRIMP 23 (1 lb) 14 (½ lb)

    Gulf shrimp boiled in Old Bay and other secret fixins, served cold with lemon and house zesty cocktail sauce

  • POTATO SKINS 13

    Loaded with cheddar cheese and bacon topped with green onions served with sour cream

  • FRIED COCONUT SHRIMP 15

    Jumbo shrimp hand-breaded in a coconut batter and deep-fried to a golden perfection, served with our tropical marmalade to dip!

  • WARM PRETZELS & BEER CHEESE 14

    4 warm soft serve salted pretzels served with beer cheese dip

  • CONCH FRITTERS 16

    Tender conch meat in a light batter, fried golden and crispy, with our remoulade

  • CHILE GLAZED YELLOWFIN TUNA 15

    Sushi grade tuna seared and glazed with sweet & spicy chili sauce

SALADS

  • SIGNATURE RUM BUCKET SALAD 10

    Spring mix and romaine blend, red onion, tomatoes, cucumbers, and pepperoncinis, topped with shredded cheese

  • CRISPY CAESAR 11

    Fresh romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese and cracked black pepper, with our housemade croutons

    Add anchovies ..... 2

  • PICK YOUR PROTEIN

    Blackened or Grilled (only for salads!):

    Chicken Breast ..... 6

    Shrimp ..... 8

    Mahi Mahi ..... 10

    Ahi Tuna ..... 10

    Sirloin Steak ..... 9

HANDHELDS

Served with your choice of seasoned fries, cole slaw, or seasonal veggies. Substitute any of our premium sides +2. Side House or Caesar Salad +3

BURGERS

All of our burgers are 1/2 lb Angus FRESH, never-frozen beef cooked to your desired temperature and served on a buttered brioche bun. Lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle chips are served on the side.

  • RUM BUCKET BURGER 15

    Signature rum glaze and provolone cheese

  • COWBOY BURGER 16

    Applewood-smoked bacon, cheddar cheese, onion ring, and a BBQ drizzle

  • SURF AND TURF 21

    Jumbo lump crab piled on our prized burger, with melted provolone, and a sprinkling of Old Bay

  • FIRECRACKER BURGER 15

    Pepper Jack cheese and our firecracker sticks served with our green pepper sauce

  • BLACK AND BLEU BURGER 16

    A perfectly blackened burger with delicately melted bleu cheese crumbles

  • MUSHROOM SWISS BURGER 15

    Topped with mushrooms and Swiss cheese

SANDWICHES

  • SMOKED SAUSAGE HOAGIE 14

    Smoked sausage on a fresh hoagie with carmelized peppers and onions

  • SHRIMP PO BOY 17

    Shrimp fried in a Cajun breading and piled on a hoagie, topped with crisp lettuce, sliced tomato, and a Cajun remoulade

  • THE BIG FISH SANDWICH
    (Seasonal)
    17

    Blackened, grilled, or fried, served on a buttered and toasted hoagie roll

  • GRILLED CHICKEN SANDWICH 16

    Juicy chicken breast on a buttered brioche bun

  • PESTO MOZZARELLA CHICKEN SANDWICH 17

    With grilled tomato and mozzarella cheese

  • ULTIMATE BLT 15

    Applewood smoked bacon, crisp lettuce, and tomato on toasted white bread

  • BLACKENED MAHI MAHI SANDWICH 19

    8oz of blackened mahi mahi, served with lettuce, tomato, and our house remoulade on the side

WRAPS

AVAILABLE TUESDAY - FRIDAY UNTIL 3PM

  • BLACKENDED SHRIMP 16

    Blackened shrimp, shredded cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, and our house remoulade

  • CHICKEN BACON RANCH 15

    Breaded crispy chicken, applewood bacon, ranch, shredded cheddar, lettuce, and tomatoes

  • BLACKENED CHICKEN CAESAR 15

    Blackened chicken breast, crisp romaine, Parmesan cheese, and a drizzle of homemade Caesar dressing

FORK & KNIFE

Entrees include your choice of 2 sides (Except Pasta Dishes). Side House or Caesar Salad +3.

  • MANGO CHILI GLAZED SHRIMP 19

    Two skewers of grilled shrimp drizzled with our mango chili glaze served over a bed of rice with fresh vegetables

  • CHOPPED STEAK 17

    Savory beef chopped steak served with a pile of mashed potatoes and mushroom gravy with fresh vegetables

  • FRIED SHRIMP BASKET 17

  • LOBSTER RAVIOLI 17

    With blackened shrimp and truffle cream sauce

  • BLACKENED CHICKEN ALFREDO*
    (Served after 3pm)
    17

    Juicy blackened chicken breast in a bed of penne pasta with our creamy Alfredo sauce

  • SHRIMP & SAUSAGE ALFREDO*
    (Served after 3pm)
    19

    With blackened shrimp and smoked sausage, in a bed of penne pasta with our creamy Alfredo sauce

  • TENDER BONE-IN PORK SHANK 21

    With a mushroom demi glaze gravy, served in a bed of homemade garlic mashed potatoes and vegetables

  • RUM BUCKET RICE BOWL 17

    Grilled chicken or shrimp, rice pilaf, grilled peppers, onions, finished with teriyaki rum glaze

  • BABY BACK RIBS MKT

    1/2 rack or full rack, smoked to perfection, served with French fries and coleslaw

  • LUMP CRAB CAKES 23

    Topped with our house remoulade sauce, served with rice and vegetables

FRESH CATCH

Fish Will Vary Seasonally. Served with your choice of two sides. Side House or Caesar Salad +3.

BLACKENED OR GRILLED
Sauces: Lemon Butter Beurre Blanc, Cajun Cream Sauce, or Our Signature Rum Glaze.

  • SNAPPER MKT

  • TRIPLE TAIL MKT

  • GROUPER MKT

  • MAHI MAHI MKT

  • RED FISH MKT

SIGNATURE STEAKS

Served with your choice of two sides. Side House or Caesar Salad +3.

  • RUM BUCKET SURF AND TURF MKT

    8oz sirloin with a shrimp skewer

  • 10OZ NEW YORK STRIP MKT

  • 8OZ SIRLOIN MKT

  • 12OZ RIBEYE MKT

  • PARMESAN CRUSTED RIBEYE MKT

  • STEAK ADD ONS

    Sweet Papas Pilar Rum Sauce ..... 2

    Peppercorn Mushroom Demi Glaze ..... 2

    Blue Cheese Crumbles ..... 2

    Sautéed Mushrooms ..... 2

    Caramelizd Onions ..... 2

    Shrimp Skewer ..... 7

SIDES

Prices are for a la carte

  • FRENCH FRIES 3

  • COLE SLAW 3

  • SEASONAL VEGGIES 3

PREMIUM SIDES

  • SIDE SALAD 5

  • MASHED POTATO 3

  • RICE PILAF 3

  • BAKED POTATO 3

    Add Cheese & Bacon ..... 2

MKT: Market Price, ask server for details

Prices, specials and menu options are subject to change and may no longer be available. Please ask your server for the most up to date information.

The Rum Bucket Bar & Grill
(239) 288-6975
5150 Buckingham Rd
Fort Myers, FL 33905
  • TheRumBucket.com
  • Copyright © 2025
  • All Rights Reserved